somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

I wonder what it's like...

I want to start this off by saying that I'm not trying to judge Atheism or Atheists, this was just something I was thinking about the other night. I'd love to see responses that are also open-minded and non-judgemental from religious people, agnostics and atheists alike.

 

The other night I was praying, when this thought came to me - what if there were no God to pray to? I got to thinking about what that would be like. I got to thinking about the times when I say prayers of thanksgiving. It was weird thinking about not being able to give thanks for things that are not human-created. I often stop on walks, for example, and give thanks for the beauty around me. If you are an atheist, what do you do when you are overcome by the beauty of nature? What about when something happens that is inexplicable - something that religious folk might consider a miracle? 

 

Then I got to thinking about death and the loved ones I have lost. I have a hard time with transitions, in general, and so when someone dies I take great comfort in the thought of an afterlife - and the chance that maybe I will be able to be with them again. Perhaps this is all selfish and preposterous, but it really helps me. I think grief would be so much harder if I didn't believe in that possibility. 

 

This all left me feeling pretty sad.

 

I'm guessing I'm not the only one here who has thought these things, so I'd love to hear your stories.

Share this

Comments

chansen's picture

chansen

image

somegalfromcan wrote:

I want to start this off by saying that I'm not trying to judge Atheism or Atheists, this was just something I was thinking about the other night. I'd love to see responses that are also open-minded and non-judgemental from religious people, agnostics and atheists alike.

 

The other night I was praying, when this thought came to me - what if there were no God to pray to? I got to thinking about what that would be like. I got to thinking about the times when I say prayers of thanksgiving. It was weird thinking about not being able to give thanks for things that are not human-created. I often stop on walks, for example, and give thanks for the beauty around me. If you are an atheist, what do you do when you are overcome by the beauty of nature?

That happens to me.  Just because I don't believe a supreme being created it, doesn't stop it from being beautiful.  It also doesn't stop me from being in awe of nature.

 

To me, it's more amazing that these things exist at all.  Attributing them to some unprovable hypothesis of a god doesn't improve these experiences at all.

 

 

somegalfromcan wrote:

What about when something happens that is inexplicable - something that religious folk might consider a miracle? 

There is the inexplicable and the highly improbable.  In the case of the improbable, well, sometimes we beat the odds.  It's that simple.  In the case of the inexplicable, we don't always have explanations.  That can be very hard to accept, but I personally prefer no explanation to a bad explanation.  I think no explanation is far more honest.

 

 

somegalfromcan wrote:

Then I got to thinking about death and the loved ones I have lost. I have a hard time with transitions, in general, and so when someone dies I take great comfort in the thought of an afterlife - and the chance that maybe I will be able to be with them again. Perhaps this is all selfish and preposterous, but it really helps me. I think grief would be so much harder if I didn't believe in that possibility. 

I suppose some situations might be easier if one believed in an afterlife.  But I tend not to change what I believe based on what I wish was true.  Given the lack of reasons to believe in an afterlife, I don't believe in it.

 

At times of loss, I am thankful for the time I had with the person.  I am thankful for their profound impact on my life, my memories, and my personality.  That's enough for me.  I think that introducing "God" into these thoughts cheapens them. 

 

 

somegalfromcan wrote:

This all left me feeling pretty sad.

I think that loss is sad.  No argument here.

carolla's picture

carolla

image

Thanks for your thoughful responses chansen. 

 

Somegal, from my perspective, let me see how I can answer your questions.  To me giving thanks, prayers of thanksgiving etc. - I sense that I can (and do) pray whenever, wherever to express that gratitude for the presence of these things, people or experiences in my life.  That's a bit more of my focus, rather than necessarily thanking God for specifically providing them - so I guess maybe I'm a bit more of a generalist in that regard, or maybe just at a different point on my faith journey.  I definitely share chansen's sense of amazement for much of what exists!

 

I don't really believe in an afterlife, in the sense of reunion etc.  So for me that's not part of the picture.  I am grateful for all who are and have been part of my journey (including YOU!) - and memories of them remain with me, even after the physical person is long gone.  Naturally there is grief and mourning of  loss - its a healthy part of being in relationship, being human. 

 

Sorry to hear you're feeling sad ... glad you're sharing.  I look forward to reading other responses to your questions.

chemgal's picture

chemgal

image

Somegal, while I'm not an athiest, this video does explain how science makes me feel:


(Starting around the 7:30 mark, if you're not interested in the whole thing).

While I do believe God put the mechanisms into place, I'm not too sure about every little change.  Just the fact that an enzyme exists is pretty amazing to me.  The mutations that had to occur to get something working that synthetically, we're very far behind.  Life itself is huge exponentially steps away from that one little enzyme.  While I do thank God for creation, I can feel a sense of gratitude, amazement, wonder and awe to many many many extremely small probablities of occurance actually occuring without that gratitude being directed to anywhere but nature itself.

somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

Chansen, Carolla and Chemgal - thank you for the thoughtful and thought-provoking replies! Keep them coming folks!

somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

chansen wrote:

That happens to me.  Just because I don't believe a supreme being created it, doesn't stop it from being beautiful.  It also doesn't stop me from being in awe of nature.

 

To me, it's more amazing that these things exist at all.  Attributing them to some unprovable hypothesis of a god doesn't improve these experiences at all.

 

I'm also in awe that these things exist. I feel lucky that I live in a place where I get to experience this awe at will. Every day I get to see vistas that include forests, the ocean and beautiful snow-capped mountains. They all take my breath away.

 

 

somegalfromcan wrote:

What about when something happens that is inexplicable - something that religious folk might consider a miracle? 

Chansen wrote:

There is the inexplicable and the highly improbable.  In the case of the improbable, well, sometimes we beat the odds.  It's that simple.  In the case of the inexplicable, we don't always have explanations.  That can be very hard to accept, but I personally prefer no explanation to a bad explanation.  I think no explanation is far more honest.

 

I was thinking about things that are, at least at this point in history, completely inexplicable. I was thinking, for example, about something that happened to me a couple of years ago. I was involved in a minor car accident in an area of town that was not close to where I live or work and I didn't think I knew anyone who lived in the area. The next day, a client came up to me at work and said that she had seen what had happened and that, if I needed it, she would back me up as a witness. Fortunately there was no damage to my body or vehicle, so I didn't need her help. All of those things put together, for me, constitute a miracle - a car accident with no injuries, no damage and a friendly face who just happened to be at the scene.

 

Chansen wrote:
At times of loss, I am thankful for the time I had with the person.  I am thankful for their profound impact on my life, my memories, and my personality.  That's enough for me.  I think that introducing "God" into these thoughts cheapens them.

 

And for me, introducing God into these thoughts enriches them.

somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

carolla wrote:

Thanks for your thoughful responses chansen. 

 

Somegal, from my perspective, let me see how I can answer your questions.  To me giving thanks, prayers of thanksgiving etc. - I sense that I can (and do) pray whenever, wherever to express that gratitude for the presence of these things, people or experiences in my life.  That's a bit more of my focus, rather than necessarily thanking God for specifically providing them - so I guess maybe I'm a bit more of a generalist in that regard, or maybe just at a different point on my faith journey.  I definitely share chansen's sense of amazement for much of what exists!

 

My prayers of thanksgiving tend to start off with specifics and then get more general. I might start by saying thanks for this specific mountain, for example, but then move into a more general thank you for all mountains and the life-giving forces on and around them.

 

Carolla wrote:

I don't really believe in an afterlife, in the sense of reunion etc.  So for me that's not part of the picture.  I am grateful for all who are and have been part of my journey (including YOU!) - and memories of them remain with me, even after the physical person is long gone.  Naturally there is grief and mourning of  loss - its a healthy part of being in relationship, being human. 

 

Sorry to hear you're feeling sad ... glad you're sharing.  I look forward to reading other responses to your questions.

 

I am also greatful for you Carolla - and for all of the folks on the Wonder Cafe (even those who I might not like all of the time). I agree that it is important to hold on to the memories of folks who have passed on. This may sound weird, but I do like to "talk" to people even after they have gone. It helps me to work through my feelings of grief and loss and it helps me to maintain a sense of connection with the person who has died.

 

Today I am not feeling as sad. I am also really looking forward to reading more responses.

carolla's picture

carolla

image

I don't actually think it's 'weird' to talk to people after they have gone.  To me, it's kind of thinking out loud, wondering what they might think or advise on matters,  imagining the humour they might find in our situations, wishing for guidance ...  Now, if you hear their voices answering you ... well, that's a bit of another matter!

 

somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

chemgal wrote:

Somegal, while I'm not an athiest, this video does explain how science makes me feel:


(Starting around the 7:30 mark, if you're not interested in the whole thing).

While I do believe God put the mechanisms into place, I'm not too sure about every little change.  Just the fact that an enzyme exists is pretty amazing to me.  The mutations that had to occur to get something working that synthetically, we're very far behind.  Life itself is huge exponentially steps away from that one little enzyme.  While I do thank God for creation, I can feel a sense of gratitude, amazement, wonder and awe to many many many extremely small probablities of occurance actually occuring without that gratitude being directed to anywhere but nature itself.

 

I really enjoyed that video Chemgal (I did watch the whole thing). I believe similarly to you in that I believe that God put the mechanisms into place, but am unsure about all of the changes/mutations. This is connected, also, to my belief in free will. I don't believe that God necessarily has a plan for each of us, but when we need help making decisions, we can go to God, through prayer, and we will get advice. Because God can't actually talk to us, the message comes through in other ways and may not be immediately obvious. We may not like the advice given and can choose whether or not to take it.

somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

carolla wrote:

I don't actually think it's 'weird' to talk to people after they have gone.  To me, it's kind of thinking out loud, wondering what they might think or advise on matters,  imagining the humour they might find in our situations, wishing for guidance ...  Now, if you hear their voices answering you ... well, that's a bit of another matter!

 

 

I'm glad to hear you don't think it is weird! No voices answer me back, thankfully - I think I'd jump out of my skin if they did!

InannaWhimsey's picture

InannaWhimsey

image

carolla wrote:

I don't actually think it's 'weird' to talk to people after they have gone.  To me, it's kind of thinking out loud, wondering what they might think or advise on matters,  imagining the humour they might find in our situations, wishing for guidance ...  Now, if you hear their voices answering you ... well, that's a bit of another matter!

 

 

i still talk to my boi -- when i'm going for an overnight stay somewhere else i tell him where i'm going and that he can come with if he wishes and that he can do anything now

somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

Awww... that's so sweet Inanna!

WaterBuoy's picture

WaterBuoy

image

Some people don't believe in what's abstract ... sort of a Shadowland that many avoid ... not knowing what's buried there as treasure ...

 

That's Legion ... into the drink again ... like Thor in the cups ... Kohl ... dark intoxicating? Some just don't have thirst ... not warmed enough to rise to the call of the other side ... what's denied as de Luce idioms ... flyte words? Is that vulgarism ... or just too common to be mean as a medium without a care?

 

Extract the powers ... bring eM to their knees! Infinite ... when there's nothing else ... that's all there is tuit! Must be observed explicitly ... exterior vision ... OBI? Get oud wit cha ...

 

Can the surrounding power sap am'n ... that's UR! In Jinn process ... all comes back at cha ... careful where yah goes ... always skett ...

somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

Thank you Waterbuoy - you have such a poetic way with words.

Back to Religion and Faith topics