I no longer feel comfortable in an organization that treat adherents as second class citizens. Rules in the United Church of Canada and its various levels of control deem that adherents are not to be trusted and must seek special dispensation to speak or vote at congregational meetings including the choice of who our leaders shall be.
Any other organization welcomes me as a full member when I have signed up, paid my dues and possibly work for the group. The United Church requires me to publically proclaim vows that I accept all their teachings even when it makes me a hypocrite to my own conscience.
Many congregations now have more adherents than full members, but the old guard still retains the only voting rights. Surely, anyone who makes the effort to attend a congregational meeting must be allowed to speak and to vote. I have worked and supported my local congregation for many years but now, as we choose a new minister, I am not allowed a choice. Either I go along with the old guard or I go to another denomination.
It is time that democracy be recognized in the United Church. Local congregations cannot be controlled by a distant Presbytry or from National Office.
I no longer feel comfortable in an organization that treat adherents as second class citizens. Rules in the United Church of Canada and its various levels of control deem that adherents are not to be trusted and must seek special dispensation to speak or vote at congregational meetings including the choice of who our leaders shall be.
Any other organization welcomes me as a full member when I have signed up, paid my dues and possibly work for the group. The United Church requires me to publically proclaim vows that I accept all their teachings even when it makes me a hypocrite to my own conscience.
Many congregations now have more adherents than full members, but the old guard still retains the only voting rights. Surely, anyone who makes the effort to attend a congregational meeting must be allowed to speak and to vote. I have worked and supported my local congregation for many years but now, as we choose a new minister, I am not allowed a choice. Either I go along with the old guard or I go to another denomination.
It is time that democracy be recognized in the United Church. Local congregations cannot be controlled by a distant Presbytry or from National Office.
No group posts at this time.
Please..go to another denomination (or Rotary or any organization) and try to make the fullest contribution possible without joining it. Good luck with that.
You are arguing about a technical detail. If you want to vote join the Church. If you don't believe the vows enough to say them don't give money to the Church either.
© WonderCafe. All Rights Reserved
Brought to you by the people of The United Church of Canada
Opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of WonderCafe or The United Church of Canada
Comments
Melchizedek
Please..go to another
Posted on: 05/24/2010 10:44
Please..go to another denomination (or Rotary or any organization) and try to make the fullest contribution possible without joining it. Good luck with that.
Serena
Second Class Membership
Posted on: 05/07/2010 16:31
You are arguing about a technical detail. If you want to vote join the Church. If you don't believe the vows enough to say them don't give money to the Church either.