MikePaterson's picture

MikePaterson

image

Christmas shopping

ARE you changing your shopping plans in vew of the ire in Bangladesh? It might be the best way to express the Christmas "spirit"…

Three managers at the Tazreen Fashions company in  Bangladeshi clothing factory were arrested and accused of locking a main gate of the factory, preventing people from escaping the recent fire that killed more than 100 workers — 200 more were injured as fled the factory in Ashulia, police said.

 

The factory was supplying Walmart, Disney, Sears and outlets in Europe and Hong Kong. Walmart promptly said Tazreen Fashions was no longer authorized to produce merchandise for the company. "A supplier subcontracted work to this factory without authorization and in direct violation of our policies. Today, we have terminated the relationship with that supplier," Wal-Mart said on Monday.

That’s hardly a persuasive move, After the fire, that factory's hardly likely that it’d be able to supply Walmart or anyone else. And it far from a guarantee that Walmart will go out of its way to ensure fires like the one at Tazreen Fashions do not happen again. They are not uncommon.

Despite decades of campaigning by labor groups and tighter legislation, factories across Asia have proved to be deathtraps for their workers. A fire at a garment factory in Karachi in October killed almost 300 workers, making it the worst factory disaster in Asia since a Thai blaze killed 188 toy factory hands in 1993.

These fires come as these sorts of industries move their production from China, where wages are rising, says Maurizio Bussi, director of the International Labor Organisation's Decent Work Team in south-east Asia. So companies move from country to country to find the cheapest pool of labor, he said.

"This is part of the natural business dynamics of a very price sensitive sector such as the garment industry," he said.

The clothing trade is highly mobile with low start-up costs, so it's often the first rung on the industrial ladder for poor countries like Bangladesh that have a large, low-skilled workforce. The systems that protect workers in these countries are not as well developed and will require further engagement and commitment from governments, local employers and foreign investors.

Isn't it time for us to express some moral care when we go shopping? We are where the "price sensitivity" begins. To help us, do we need some sort of independent supply chain policing body? Do we need labelling requirements? Is responsibility our own? After all, Canada is still exporting asbestos to these sorts of very poor, struggling countries… are we morally capable of this?

 

 

 

Share this

Comments

somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

I try to purchase gifts that are ethically responsible for Christmas. I tend to purchase gifts that fall into one of the following categories: an experience (for example, tickets to a concert or hockey game), locally made (crafts), supportive of a charity (for example a stuffed animal in support of the local children's health foundation) or fair trade (I head to my local Ten Thousand Villages store).

MikePaterson's picture

MikePaterson

image

I've been personally boycotting Walmart for all sorts of reasons for so long I'm not sure when I began. Ten Thousand Villages is my No.1 shop too.

somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

I feel the same way about Walmart Mike - I refuse to set foot in the place.

Kimmio's picture

Kimmio

image

I haven't been to Walmart in over 2 years. Sorry to say, it's not necessarily because of their ethics, although I wish that was the reason for my decision. I'd like to say it was because I was being ethically responsible, but in truth it's more because it'stoo far from where we live,  and I don't drive so I am too lazy to go all the way there on the bus, pay for transit two zones, and try to carry stuff home. The last time we went there, some household items we needed were majorly cheaper than anywhere else and we have a tight budget. So it is very tempting. So, maybe it's good that it's not close to where I live because I hate what they do. I suppose that I haven't even attempted to go back is a good sign, because I am conscious of how bad Walmart is--and not having a car limits where we shop. I just wonder, if I did have a car would I be more tempted o go there? Maybe. But I would think twice.

 

I haven't really done any shopping for anything other than groceries and toiletries lately. I sometimes buy second hand things--my mom, over the past few years, did a great job of helping us find second hand stuff we need, also. She likes to do it.

 

I like Ten Thousand Villages. There was one in my neighbourhood that shut down. It didn't get enough business, so went out of business last year. There is still another one in a neighbouring neighbourhood. I find it out of my price league, except for really the small items. There was some furniture in there that I was gaga over, but there's no way we could buy it. It's fun to look though

We're not buying anything. Other thanI might buy some craft supplies to make a few gifts and cards. Which means I miught buy the supplies from Michaels because it's the only one I know around...but are they like the Walmart of craft supplies?

 

 

Rowan's picture

Rowan

image

Most people on my list are getting baskets of home-made preserves, home-baked goodies and hand-knit (by me) dishcloths.  The main reasons for this being 1) almost no one gave me want lists for gifts. 2) I went bonkers with the canning this past summer so I have more canned stuff than I need and thus plenty to give away. 3) I loath christmas shopping. Actually I loath shopping period  -  I am one of those people who goes in with a list and a plan to get the items on the list and get back out again in the shortest time possible, but it's way worse when everyone and their dog is in the mall at the same time I am.

somegalfromcan's picture

somegalfromcan

image

Rowan - that sounds like such a wonderful gift! Homemade gifts always give me a thrill - for me the effort and care put into making something like that make the gift worth far more than anything that could be bought in a store. 

 

I feel the same way about shopping as you Rowan - I go with a purpose and get out as quickly as possible! There are very few exceptions to that rule - one exception being Ten Thousand Villages. I could drool over their items for hours - even if much of it is out of my price range.

Dcn. Jae's picture

Dcn. Jae

image

This year I have narrowed my holiday shopping list down to three people: my mother, my wife, and my youngest stepson. I'm not really sure about where I'll be shopping. My mom wants a pair of simple silver earrings. I might get those at Winners at the local mall. I always find shopping for my wife difficult, and she has a tendancy to re-gift things I give her anyway. I pick out something special for her, but when she thinks someone needs it more, she just gives it away. For my son who's coming home from college, I should probably give him something automobile related, since he's studying auto mechanics right now. I don't really know where to buy something like that. I try to buy things I think the giftee will like. Where it comes from, or what it's made of, or who made it are things of greatly less importance to me. I tell myself each year things like I'll make all the gifts, or else I'll buy them all at church craft sales, etc., but I never do.

kaythecurler's picture

kaythecurler

image

I'm trying to think of something that I'll be buying!  My partner gets a gift when he mentions something he wants and needs but doesn't have the cash for.  Sometimes this happens around the time of the Holiday of Light and Love, sometimes at some other point of the year.  My adult kids have more 'stuff' and cash than is necessary already.  I write cheques for the grands so they can practise decision making.

 

One of my adult kids told me that I'm boring because I don't use shopping as a hobby.  I have absolutely no interest in wandering around stores looking at endless rows of things I neither need nor want.  For me shopping means grabbing the list and getting what is on it, preferably quickly.

Back to Global Issues topics
cafe