Pakistan is even more dangerous than the middle east - even though the middle east is a key to US military and economic power. An American man shot and killed two, young Pakistan men. He was arrested.. The US insisted he be released because of diplomatic immunity.
One problem with that is he was never registered as a diplomat - and he has a career record of being a US intelligence agent. The US is desparate to get him out - even offering to pay large compensation to the victims of the family and to exchange a Pakistani scientist being held in the US. Obama is obviously worried about what this man might say to get a deal in court.
If the arrest had been made by national authorities, there would be no problem. The government of Pakistan is made up of American stooges. But he was arrested and charged in the Punjab. That government is the political opposition of the national government. The region (indeed, all of Pakistan) is furious about the murders, doubly so becaue of American drone attacks on Pakistan - and the high probability that the killer is the man who has been spotting targets for the drones.
This could lead to general disgust with the national government, an overturning of it, and a Pakistan with its nuclear weapons controlled by people who have no reason to love the US. Even the extradition of the killer would be likely to lead to the overthrow of the national government.
© WonderCafe. All Rights Reserved
Brought to you by the people of The United Church of Canada
Opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of WonderCafe or The United Church of Canada
Comments
stardust
Posted on: 02/20/2011 00:18
graeme
Some news from the net:
The Nation/Asia News Network
LAHORE/ISLAMABAD - The Chief Justice of Lahore High Court Friday directed the Punjab police to arrest the driver of the US consulate's vehicle which had crushed to death a Pakistani following murder of two citizens by a US national, Raymond Davis.
The court passed this order on a petition moved by Ijazul Rehman, the brother of deceased Ibadur Rehman. The petitioner sought free and fair investigations into the case.
The US consulate's vehicle carrying two persons overran motorcyclist Ibad while rushing to help Davis who was detained after he shot down two Pakistanis at Cordoba Chowk on Jan 27. Ibad died on the spot while the jeep sped to the US consulate where the inmates are believed to have taken shelter
US lawmakers threaten to cut Pakistan
aid
http://www.dawn.com/2011/02/10/us-lawmakers-threaten-to-cut-pakistan-aid.html
stardust
Posted on: 02/20/2011 00:17
I got more on the story here. It doesn't sound very good. Executed....??? Yikes...!!!
A court in Lahore on Thursday put off ruling on whether the American had immunity until March 14.
Police accuse Davis of cold-blooded murder and religious hardliners, already out defending controversial blasphemy laws, have taken to the streets afresh clamouring for Davis to be executed.
http://www.dawn.com/2011/02/17/grieving-families-caught-in-pakistan-us-storm.html
graeme
Posted on: 02/20/2011 10:18
This is the inevitable extension of te war against Afghanistan to a war against Pakistan.
Combine that with resistance in the middle east and latin america, and we may be wathing a collapse of the american empire much more quickly than I though possible.
stardust
Posted on: 02/20/2011 16:45
Its really bad stuff graeme. Donald Trump may run in the election but its really too late for the U.S.A. no matter who runs. Nobody can fix it as it goes deeper and deeper into the mire.
Quote:
Further complicating the situation, a Pakistani intelligence official said that the two men Davis killed were not, as he has said, armed robbers intent on stealing money, his telephone and perhaps his car, but intelligence agents assigned to tail him. This official said the two intended to frighten Davis because he crossed a "red line" that the official did not further define.
Both the military's Inter-Services Intelligence service and the Interior Ministry's Intelligence Bureau regularly use motorcycle tails to track the movement of U.S. officials, another Pakistani official said.
On Sunday, the widow of one of the men killed by Davis committed suicide in the city of Faisalabad. According to a doctor at the hospital where she was admitted after ingesting rat poison, she said she did it because she feared Davis would be released without facing trial.
(
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/02/07/AR2011020705790_2.html
The other interesting angle is the involvement of US President Barack Obama in the case and his issuing a statement also saying that Raymond Davis had diplomatic immunity. It is highly unusual for the US president to get personally involved in a matter involving an apparently low-ranking employee of any US embassy.
Even the US Congress is asking interesting questions. For instance, if Raymond Davis is a diplomat, then why was he carrying weapons? And if he is indeed a diplomat then what was he doing in Pakistan’s border areas, taking photographs and carrying a GPS decoder? There are also reports that he posed as a convert and tried to establish links with banned outfits in Pakistan. Is the Pakistan government going to stay silent on this issue of a US ‘diplomat’ spying in Pakistan? And what about his combat experience in Afghanistan? I am quite sure that combat experience is not among the requirements for becoming a diplomat. Neither is skill in the use of arms, nor is undercover work. All of these, however, are requirements if one wants to join the ranks of counter-intelligence and espionage. ( I lost the link for this)
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703561604576150700376521050
stardust
Posted on: 02/20/2011 16:56
Edit: moved to new topic. See Donald Trump.
graeme
Posted on: 02/20/2011 18:37
There is no evidence whatever that he is a diplomat of any sort. He was carrying no diplomatic idientification. His passport was the regular one. The only infor Obama has made public is some diplomatic IDs that were printed after the arrest, and back dated.
I think Obama is very afraid of what he might say at a trial.
Jim Kenney
Posted on: 02/22/2011 12:39
My hope is that Davis will face justice in Pakistan's court system. Maybe this will force the American military to get rid of a very bad strategy.
graeme
Posted on: 02/22/2011 13:15
I hope he lives that long. Both the American and Pakistani governments would find it better if he were to suddently become fatally ill. Both almost certainly have the capacity to get to him, even in a prison.
graeme
Posted on: 02/22/2011 22:11
The case of Pakistan is much worse than I thought. It seems Davis is the acting head of the CIA in that part of the world. There are reports of him choosing targets for drones and, much worse, some reports of him supplying "biological agents" to Moslem terrorists for use against American targets. That's not as wild as it sounds. The US may want an excuse for a war on Pakistan - something like Saddam's weapons of mass destruction.
What is known for certain is that he was contracted to the CIA by Blackwater - and Pakistan could well be on the edge of a civil war over this. It is also known that all US news agencies have been aware of who Davis is since this started - but had not published it on the orders of the White House. Only when the truth appeared in British papers did the White House lift its ban. The New York Times has admitted all this.
There's a great many things the US news media have not told Americans about.
Alex
Posted on: 02/22/2011 22:49
One thing that I worry about is that the US establishment will rush to start another world war, in order to divert attention from those that wrecked their economy, and as an way to jump start their economy.
I am hoping that the Arab countries quickly form a federation after getting new governments. This would be a could be a good strategy to empower them when standing up against The US and Israel.
stardust
Posted on: 02/22/2011 23:49
graeme
quote:
"There are reports of him choosing targets for drones and, much worse, some reports of him supplying "biological agents" to Moslem terrorists for use against American targets. That's not as wild as it sounds. The US may want an excuse for a war on Pakistan - something like Saddam's weapons of mass destruction."
SCARY STUFF .
graeme
Posted on: 02/23/2011 10:51
It's as scary as it can get. Only part of the reason is that such a war would be difficult to limit. It looks as though the neo-cons are making one, last and desparate attempt to dominate the world economy through military force - just as they promised in their project for the new American Century.
Oh - has anyone seen the news that in its border agreement with the US, the two countries are making plans of how to deal with civil unrest. Each country (presumably at the request of the other) could send troops to the other. That could mean canadian troops being used to shoot at American rioters. Or American troops moving in to Canada on the excuse of protecting the oil fields. It would also mean an even futher integrationof the Canadian and American military which, so far, has made it impossible for Canada to use its mlitary in any independent way. And we become the prisoners of American policy.
stardust
Posted on: 02/23/2011 16:38
graeme
Bits and Bites of News:
Feb. 23 update. Will it make a difference to the Davis case if its true?
Quote:
Pakistan’s politicians have concerns other than legal niceties, though. Parts of the country’s press have long reported the presence of legions of US spies supposedly seeking to rob Pakistan of its nuclear weapons. Reporting of the Davis case has been peppered with claims that he was photographing military installations. In fact, the contents of Mr Davis’ camera have been disclosed: he was taking tourist snaps of buffalos blocking traffic, camel carts and other exotic aspects of street life – and the supposedly secret military installations he was said to be keen to photograph can be seen in three-dimensional glory on the internet.
Farcical as the claims might be, the polemic resonates in a country where the US is widely held to be responsible for precipitating a conflict that has led to the deaths of thousands in nationwide terrorist strikes. Public outrage has swelled because of lurid accounts of civilian casualties in US drone attacks within Pakistan’s borders – even though those operations are sanctioned by the military.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/8344078/US-pawn-ensnared-in-Pakistans-power-politics.html
graeme
Posted on: 02/23/2011 21:10
well, the first source I would distrust is The Telegraph. Look at the use of language in that report, at the downplaying of Davis' background, at the failure to say where its information is coming from For Britain, the best are The Manchester Guardian and The Independent.
Davis' background is not in doubt. He owns a "security" business (i.e. he rents out thugs). He was under contract to the CIA. The Telegraph says the two men were gangsters working for Pakistan intelligence. Quite possibly so. But I find the next part hard to believe.
They dorve up waving guns. Davis did a quick draw and killed both before they could shoot him. Really? I doubt whether even Wild Bill Hickock was that fast or accurate.
Is Davis a pawn? You bet. Most of Pakistan is furious at American drone bombings. Their have been over a hundred and sixty of them. And any reliable source I have seen says innocent civilians have been, by far, the majority of casuaties.
As well, the district where he is held is led by the national opposition party. At this point, anybody who released Davis would probably set off a civil war.
If Davis was not a spy, why was he there to meet a senior CIA official? If he was a spy, what does it matter whether his camera had tourist photos in it?
If he was a diplomat, how come there is no record of him ever having been a diplomat in his life? How come he wasn't listed as one?
Why did the White House immediately request all American news media to avoid the story? (The NY Times has admitted that much; and says the ban was lifted only when news agencies alll over the world were covering it.)
We don't yet know the whole story. We know enough that we can be sure The Telegraph is doing a coverup. And that's normal for The Telegraph - as it is for many news media.
Consider this possibility. Neo-Conservatives announced almost twenty years ago (Project for the New American Century) that the US had a window of opportunity to economically dominate the world through the use of military power. That is the origin of Iraq and Afghanistan fighting - and drone bombing of Pakistan.
The wars, and domestic greed, have ruined the economy; and the American military have not been able to win a military dominance. The window of opportunity is closing fast. What if the time has come for desparate measures - like taking out the only Moslem country that has nuclear weapons?
stardust
Posted on: 02/24/2011 01:10
graeme
I don't know......it boggles my mind! There were 5 other guys living with Davis, CIA it says ? I find the Paki-U.S. relations totally confusing. Do you think Bin Laden is there if he's even alive? How would the U.S. get around the Paki nukes re war?
Faerenach
Posted on: 02/24/2011 15:49
We had a speaker in from Afghanistan/Pakistan into Church House last month. He was reporting on the successes of farming education projects sponsored by the Canadian Foodgrains Bank and was, predictably, asked about the presence of violence and terrorism in Pakistan.
He reminded us that Pakistan has had both a flood and a drought in the past year, and that there were families growing inedible plants to eat - because they had no other access to food. To feed a family, it is not incomprehensible for a man to make the decision to find work for a terrorist organisation.
It hit me - like anywhere else, Pakistan is full of people. Like anywhere else. Yes, there are 'evildoers'... but so often we don't realize why they have the followers they do. It made the work the Canadian Foodgrains Bank was doing seem incredibly relevant, and I had the strong feeling we weren't doing enough of that type of work.
graeme
Posted on: 02/24/2011 19:23
Quite so. The west has also been noted for its failure to extent much help to Pakistan in those terrible conditions. Nor has our news media paid much attention to the scale of civilian dead in American drone attacks.
The role of al quaeda has probably been much exaggerated. Our press uses the term pretty loosely to mean just about any group that is both terrorist and Moslem. People in that part of the world don't need encouragement to hate the US. In the case of Pakistan, the US has poured money out to corrupt leaders and to the army brass. But rather little help in feeding families. Pakistani intelligence has always been ambivalent about working with the US. They don't trust the US. And with good reason.
The bankrolling of dictators and their armies was the same with Khaddafi and , even more so, with Mubarak.
Latest reports, by the way, suggest that Davis shot the two intelligence agents in the back. That seems far more plausible than The Telegraph story. Oh, and his camera did not have just tourist sites on it.
stardust
Posted on: 02/25/2011 19:36
Faerenach
Yes, living conditions for the poor in Pakistan are hellish. I was reading that many are committing suicide, no hope at all. Supposedly there was 815 million donated or pledged but I'm thinking like in Haiti it probably hasn't been forthcoming. Canada donated 46 million from the people, gov't supposed to match it. Today I read they donated part of it then, 19 million, and the rest now. I read that the people and gov'ts have donor fatigue plus there's no trust re dispensation. Its a horror show, very sad. Canada says it gave 71 million in total.
From the net:
Feb.25 Update- Canada aid
Today's announcement of $27.8 million, combined with a previously announced $19 million, totals the $46.8 million in the Pakistan Flood Relief Fund.
http://www.marketwire.com/press-release/Canada-Helps-Millions-Affected-by-Pakistans-Floods-1402084.htm
Movie stars to donate 1.5 million next week
Nadeem Hanif http://www.thenational.ae/news/uae-news/stars-help-raise-1-5m-for-pakistans-flood-victims
Wikileaks:
In one document, a team of civil affairs soldiers reports donating money for an orphanage that is supposed to help about 100 fatherless children and finding later that only about 30 boys and girls were being helped. Also missing were the stores of rice, grain and cooking oil that the troops had provided. "We found very few orphans living there and could not find most of the HA [humanitarian assistance] we had given them," the report states.
Other reports give accounts of police chiefs skimming the pay of their patrol officers or placing nonexistent "ghost" troops on their rolls so that they could pocket the additional salaries.
Pakistan or Afghan:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/07/25/AR2010072502092_2.html
stardust
Posted on: 02/25/2011 21:15
graeme
I'm still digging around for updates. I can't vouch for the truth of any of it.
'Davis had close links with Taliban'
Investigators recovered 158 items from Davis, including a 9mm Glock pistol, 75 bullets, a GPS device, an infrared torch, a wireless set, two mobile phones, a digital camera, a survival kit, five ATM cards and Pakistani and US currency.
Intelligence officials claimed these items proved that Davis was involved in "activities detrimental to Pakistan's national interests."
Davis double-murder hearing adjourned until March 3 after he refuses to sign challan
One more meaning is inclusion in a case is also a challan in northern states. One has been challaned means he has been implicated in that criminal case.
"Challan kar diya" means he has been either implicated by police or vehicle has been impleaded in any matter by any lawful authority like RTO, Excise/taxation authorities etc.
stardust
Posted on: 02/25/2011 21:26
Net News Continued:
By Greg Miller and Karen DeYoung
Washington Post Staff Writers
Thursday, February 10, 2011; 12:00 AM
Davis identifies himself as an American and repeatedly pleads with his interrogators to help him locate a passport that he says went missing shortly after he showed it to police at the crime scene.
A Pakistani intelligence official told The Washington Post that the motorcyclists were intelligence agents; a spokesman for Pakistan’s main intelligence agency denied that Tuesday.
“U.S. and Pakistani officials” agreed that the police report, written in Urdu, indicates that the two Pakistanis who were killed had robbed two individuals earlier in the day and taken their cellphones, which were found in their possession at the crime scene. These robbery victims came forward independently after seeing television coverage of the crime, saying they recognized the two Pakistanis who were shot by the U.S. official.
The report indicates that at least one of the motorcycle men cocked a weapon and aimed it at Davis while he was stopped at a traffic signal, but that neither of the Pakistani men fired.
“One cocked a pistol and pointed it at him,” a U.S. official said.
The two slain Pakistanis were found in possession of five cellular phones, a Rolex-style watch and four different types of currency, the report indicates.
comments from this site:
http://my.firedoglake.com/jimwhite/2011/02/07/raymond-davis-update-victims-were-spies-second-house-junket-and-widow-suicide/#comments
Lahore, where the event went down, is a very strange place for Davis to have been. It’s way over on the border with India, across the country from Peshawar and the Afghanistan border and well away from the capital in Islamabad, as well. This just gets more and more curious as it goes on.
Here’s the CIA Pakistan map:
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/maps/maptemplate_pk.html
graeme
Posted on: 02/26/2011 12:19
We may never know the truth. Very often, governments don't know the truth - or they hide it - as in the case of Oliver North.
InannaWhimsey
Posted on: 06/16/2011 19:20
Convert or die?
graeme
Posted on: 06/16/2011 20:57
Actually, some of the truth did come out on this one. Most of what the American authorities said was lies. Davis was a CIA agent working with a ring in Pakistan. The two men he shot were Pakistan intelligence officers assigned to follow him. And, as we know, Davis is now home and free.
EasternOrthodox
Posted on: 06/17/2011 16:20
Pakistan is in sad shape. This CIA thing is just one tiny thing in the bucket of Pakistan worries.
The floods that Stardust documents were devastating. But with people making threats about non-Muslims coming in to help, aid agencies are reluctant.
They have been going downhill ever since the Islamic fundamentalists became prominent, was is Zia Ul-Huq I believe it was. This was not the intent of the founders of Pakistan. It is very sad because most of the population just wants to live a normal life, but the government is infiltrated with fundamentalists, who keep making everyone's life miserable.
The dispute over Kashmir has also been very bad for Pakistan. We can blame Britain for that.
InannaWhimsey
Posted on: 06/17/2011 16:24
So maybe what is going to happen/is happening is 'Western Interests' are going to be 'invading' Pakistan and certain other countries to make sure that the Jihadists are kept in check and never voted in to power (which presents problems for 'Democratic' countries).
graeme
Posted on: 06/17/2011 18:13
'US aid has never been very starry. Nor has Canada's. The US still has not delivered any of the aid it promised to Haiti so long ago. But it has found the time and resources to provide increased "aid" in the form of weapons to places like Bahrain.
The US could have extended aid to Pakistan through Moslem agencies. (Yes, I know. Moslem agencies would be corrupt - unlike ours.). All help to Pakistan going back for years has been in weapons and corruption. They don't give a damn about suffering.
EasternOrthodox
Posted on: 06/17/2011 21:51
It doesn't matter what I say. If I say 2 + 2 = 4, Graeme will twist that into a negative comment somehow.
Mely
Posted on: 06/18/2011 01:16
It doesn't matter what I say. If I say 2 + 2 = 4, Graeme will twist that into a negative comment somehow.
Yup.
graeme
Posted on: 06/18/2011 10:13
thank you, EO abd Mely. Your most articulate posts yet.