graeme's picture

graeme

image

The way we see things....

Like most of us, I guess, I grew up in a world in which we can readily see evil, and identify pure evil as a cause of events.

Specifically, I grew up to see Hitler and Stalin and Mao as evil, and the terrible destruction of life that arose from them as something caused by their evil. I still think they're evil. But the second part of that sentence may be simplistic.

It may be that Hitler and Stalin and Mao were the norms for our new world - not exceptions, but terrible examples of a new normalcy.

I remember the Dieppe raid. I was a very young child at the time. But I remember the horror expressed when it was learned that Hitler had ordered Canadian prisoners from that raid to be put in handcuffs and manacles. It was widely used as an example of the barbarity of Hitler. And it was barbarous.

More recently, there were TV shots of Afghani prisoners arriving at Guantanamo. They were age 12 to 80 or so, all naked and taped to planks, gagged and blindfolded. Soldiers were unloading them like crates. They must have been like that for a couple of days for the trip.It was a barbarity that made Hitler look good.

Most of them would spend years in the prison, undergoing regular torture. Of all 750 going through Guantanamo, most never had charges laid - and probably no more than 80 will ever face charges - despite all the advantages of a military court and legal torture.

One can add to that the wide and indiscriminate slaughter of innocent people in some millions from Vietnam, Guatemala, Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan and many more to come. And, just as we once blamed Hitler and Germans, it now seems reasonable to blame Bush and Americans. But we may be wrong in both cases.

War has changed over the past century. The killing is far more indiscriminate - partly because of the power of modern weapons - and our indifference to the killing has become stunning. (How many Canadians have been killed in Afghanistan? How many Americans in Iraq? And quick now - how many mercenaries on our side have been killed? How many Iraqis? How many Afghanis, Pakistanis? We probably know the number for Canadians, and possibly for American troops in Iraq. For the others? not likely. Because we really don't give a damn..)

The problem is not that evil men have arisen. And is not that any nation is by nature evil.

The problem is that we have all become barbarous or indifferent to barbarity. Hitler and Stalin were not aberrations. They were models of where we were and still are going.

I really don't know where one goes from there. But I do know that before going anywhere, we first have to figure where we really are.

 

Share this

Comments

graeme's picture

graeme

image

we see the same actions very differently depending on who does them.

Today, out boy Cannon will meet with Ghadafi to express outrage over Libya's welcome to the Lockerbie bomber who was recently released from a British prison. Canadians in general almost certainly applaud this move.

In 1976, an Air Cubana jet was bombed, killing some 73 passengers and crew.  In the same period, there were other terrorist acts, including bombing in resort hotels in Cuba. Several men were arrested and tried in Venezuela. Most were on record as CIA operatives, and were trained at Fort Benning in Georgia.

One got off, largely on technicalities, went to the US, and is now living as a hero in Miami. One was able to fell to the US where he was arrested for illegal entry. All attempts to extradite him were denied. Bush senior pardoned him, and he, too now lives a hero in florida.

There are thousands of entries on this in google, so it isn't hard to check. Interestingly, very few are from the mainstream north american press. Some are from questionable sources- but others are quite sound, and there is no reason to doubt the essential elements.

Can you even imagine our Mr. Cannon threatening to give a dressing down to a US president over this? Can you or I really see the Lockerbie and the Air Cubana incidents as being much the same? Can we really summon up the same anger at both?

SLJudds's picture

SLJudds

image

I knew atrocities were going to happen at the start of the Afghan conflict when Bush declared himself and the U.S. as outside the rules of the Geneva Accord and not subject to War Crimes prosecution.

While I supported military action in Afghanistan, I believe now that Canada should have reviewed their contribution to the war at that point - but it was actually impossible, as the U.S. would have taken vengance against us.

graeme's picture

graeme

image

you may very well be right. And that's surely the logic that Chretien was following. Sometimes, realities are a tremendous block to ideals.

graeme's picture

graeme

image

well, this thread isn't going to work. What I was trying to get at is this. We don't see the world as Christians would. We see it as Canadians, as partners in a western alliance. Our Christianity gets all mixed up in that, and ceases to be Christianity at all.

And under cover of that mixture, we have drifted into an age of unprecedented brutality. Far from shaping our response, Christianity has become something that deepens our prejudices and fears to make us all the more accepting of brutality and all the more ready to justify it.

We have somehow lost the capacity to see the rest of the world as Christians would, or even to see it as human like us.

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

So what are you doing to prevent all this war ..... from your chair that is ?

InannaWhimsey's picture

InannaWhimsey

image

 

Didn't you know, jesouhaite777, from time immemorial, there has been a big business in WAR CHAIRS.

 

You should've seen the Barcaloungers...they were SWEET!

 

 

Just a Self-writing poem,

Inannawhimsey

Pilgrims Progress's picture

Pilgrims Progress

image

graeme wrote:

Like most of us, I guess, I grew up in a world in which we can readily see evil, and identify pure evil as a cause of events.

Specifically, I grew up to see Hitler and Stalin and Mao as evil, and the terrible destruction of life that arose from them as something caused by their evil. I still think they're evil. But the second part of that sentence may be simplistic.

I don't see anyone as evil, but rather their acts often are. Once we see certain people as being evil, it becomes all to easy to project all  evil on the other, and leave the "goodness" with ourselves. (Jesus warned against this way of thinking when he talked of paying attention to the speck in your brother's eye while we have a log in our own eye.)

I saw a disturbing programme on t.v. about how easy it is to follow orders when asked by those in authority to commit atrocities. Twenty people were told they would be taking part in a science project led by a prominent scientist. Basically, they each had to ask a series of questions to a subject. Everytime the subject gave a wrong answer they had to give him an electric shock of escalating intensity. They were clearly told it would eventually be enough to kill the subject. The subject's "distress" could clearly be heard.

Only three out of the twenty refused to continue with the experiment when met with the distress of the subject. I was horrified to see that all women co-operated to the point of "death". The point being that when they heard  the subject scream out they all turned to the white coated "scientist", and said tentatively "is it okay to continue?" When told it was necessary, and they were helping science, they simply followed the orders of the "scientist".

Personally, like a lot of women, I was raised to be  a "good" girl. In reality, this often meant to follow authority figures, particularly my parents. After seeing this documentary, I've resolved to follow my own will in future.

The_Omnissiah's picture

The_Omnissiah

image

Well Jes, he sure as hell speaks out on issues. Which is a lot more than some people do.

 

 

THE WAR CHAIR!

As-salaamu alaikum

-Omni

jesouhaite777's picture

jesouhaite777

image

Mostly dead issues .......

Most people are brain dead and can't think for themselves so of course they would listen to someone in charge ....

We don't see the world as Christians would.

That is laughable Christians would not have behaved any differently if they were asked to follow a Hitler or a Stalin they would have been just as cowardly .... turn the other cheek that is what they do.

I saw a disturbing programme on t.v. was it The Stanford prison experiment ?

One of the most famous experiments done

 

Pilgrims Progress's picture

Pilgrims Progress

image

jesouhaite777 wrote:

I saw a disturbing programme on t.v. was it The Stanford prison experiment ?

One of the most famous experiments done

 

No. It was part of a UK documentary called "The Truth About Violence."

Back to Politics topics
cafe