graeme's picture

graeme

image

My failure to understand Christianity

let's presume that some wars are good, and that going to war in Afghanistan was a Christian thing to do. Okay.

That war was lost years ago, even back in the Bush days. Indeed, it has turned out to be the most expensive military blunder in history. It has long been known that we are leaving AFghanistan, precisely because our leaders know we cannot win. So why is it taking so long to leave? Because our leaders don't want to be blamed for the defeat. And so they can avoid blame,

We are killing people by numbers our governments won't tell us - killing them by violence, by starvation, by exposure. Today's news carried a story of a mass rape of women in a village carried out by American troops. We are also risking lives of our own, NATO troops for no reason but to spare politicians from embarassment. (and, of course, next Nov. 11 we shall piously remember those who died to save freedom.)

Unless I am dreadfully confused, that is what sin is. I wonder how many churches had services or discussions about this. I would expect it's been damn few. And I expect to hear that, after all, it makes congregants uneasy to drag these issues into church - or the church has no business discussing politics. After all, we don't want to upset people. Too bad our churches were around at the time to straigten out Jesus on his habit of upsetting some people.

Odd. The churches had no problem discussing politics when Hitler launched his wars. And since politicis is the means by which we make social decisions, I cannot understand how a church can stay out of the political world..

I live in New Brunswick where politics and big business are stunningly corrupt, corrupting and, by any definition, immoral. The people of this province have been robbed blind since Confederation - and well before it. Where the hell have the churches been?

I quite understand the principle of separation of church and state. But that's not the problem here because in Canada, the church and state are not separate. On the contrary, the churches fully cooperate in silent blessing for all the immorality of government and big business. I wish we did have separation of church and state. As it is, though, the church usually stands by as an idle spectator with occasional intervention to bless the status quo.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share this

Comments

graeme's picture

graeme

image

well, I do weight lifting. I'm hoping, in the foreseeable future, to be beautiful.

alta's picture

alta

image

It seems to me that it would help if more "Christians" started acting like Christians.

My.02

graeme's picture

graeme

image

My point precisely.

Jim Kenney's picture

Jim Kenney

image

Hi graeme, thank you for the chuckle.  Maybe it is the outcome of being a teacher and outdoor enthusiast before entering ministry.   I will keep your comments in mind as I work on both my looking ahead posts and my sermons.

redhead's picture

redhead

image

you bait  all the time graeme

WaterBuoy's picture

WaterBuoy

image

There is an old saying about power corrupting ...

 

Then there is a verse about God being humble ...

 

Could people that believe they have to power of religion behind eM ... reconcile this sense of diversity?

 

It would appear to take a broad base of wisdom ... then many ministers say don't thnk and preach about staying away from the tree of knowledge and all related events. The garden collapsed into Gehenna ... go fig Ur ... was it just a challenge for mediums? These things are not well-accepted in the temple ...

 

But if we keep our neighbours in the dark ... whose advantage is that?

 

"Go teach my children"! Appears to be received in many churches as so much bull. Consider the effect of spending trillions in the Middle East teaching broad based knowledge rather than peddling the mechanics of war; would that be a road to change?

 

Yet in the eyes of many ignorance is good ... a state of bliss ... not knowing! Sometimes a fine break leading us back to that different reality ...

Alia's picture

Alia

image

The "church" does imho speak up re political issues...the church is made up of individual believers ...the church is not a denomination or a building.....I don't think we should be looking for particular "groups " to be coming out with political statements and broadbrushing everyone in that group has having the same convictions on an issue...but if an individual believer feels a conviction to speak up about injustices...they sould do that. 

graeme's picture

graeme

image

Yes. I think the emphasis should be on the Christian context rather than the cause

Even that has its own dangers, though, as some people can come to rather peculiar ideas of what the Bible says.

I feel uncomfortable with the church itself adopting a cause - even if I agree with the cause. It should, perhaps, be more a place where people are encouraged think of what a Christian context means and, quite separately from the worship serivce, a place that acts as a clearing house and contact centre for organizations that might interest congregants.

I think churches should have produced CCF leaders like Woodsworth and Douglas. But I don't think the Methodist/United/Baptist church should have campaigned for them.

One group that was designed to produce children who would think in an independent but Christian context was the CGIT (Canadian Grandmothers in Trousers, as we called them.) I don't know how effective the group was. but the idea of it was interesting.

WaterBuoy's picture

WaterBuoy

image

Context ... would that include past and future conceptions in consideration of how we do things today ... or just continue in the present mode without a clue for syntax ... how the communication connects ... mostly a dis connect in the present strenghts ... where wecannot go there  ... to the past lessons (ancient wisdom literacy) or how the present  errors might lead on ... to further rapture ... vacant thoughts? How it isn't!

 

Then, I can speakof non sense for tomorrow, for who really gives a chit beyond today ...? keeps the genus happy ... ignorance about how it all play soude ...

 

Is ignorance like an unconscious mind? In cognate reception of the alien ...

yogggiii's picture

yogggiii

image

Life sucks much of the time. So does government and so does church. We each must make our own relationship with God, however we conceive of God. We can no longer believe the fairy tales and myth. We must become spiritual and not religious. How can we be expected to believe things that were written by people far removed from our time and culture who, compared to our western technological society, lived in ignorance. We don't know who they were, what they thought, what their beliefs were or anything about them. We must come to our own relationship with god; one that makes sense to us. It does take committment, a lot of reading and discussing and meditation and prayer. The joy is in the journey. It doesn't happen simply by going to church for an hour on Sunday.

Arminius's picture

Arminius

image

Well, yogggiii, you really are a Yogi, eh?smiley

not4prophet's picture

not4prophet

image

yogggiii wrote:

 How can we be expected to believe things that were written by people far removed from our time and culture who, compared to our western technological society, lived in ignorance.

 

That would be true of what is written pertaining to actual worldly things including religions created by mankind. It need not include the ideals behind those religions if they lead mankind in a direction less aggressive and oppressive, a thinking universal across time..

graeme's picture

graeme

image

following that line of thought, where do we get our idea of what a relationship with God should be?Anybody out there who is doing that from scratch must be very, very brilliant, indeed.

not4prophet's picture

not4prophet

image

Thank you. lol

Neo's picture

Neo

image

graeme wrote:

following that line of thought, where do we get our idea of what a relationship with God should be?Anybody out there who is doing that from scratch must be very, very brilliant, indeed.

This is one of my sources Graeme, 24 books written by Alice A. Bailey and the Tibetan Master Djwhal Khul between 1922 and 1949.

not4prophet's picture

not4prophet

image

 

It doesn't take a genius to figure what it is that mankind does wrong, nor the solution. It would take a super human being to follow the ways of goodness daily, not once justifying deeds, be they good or evil. It only takes a regular human being to try.

Jim Kenney's picture

Jim Kenney

image

Well said, not4prophet!

WaterBuoy's picture

WaterBuoy

image

Superhuman is that beyond or just in the abstract ... imaginary side of soul?

 

There is a certain sense of paraiah about IT ... as if anonymous, unknown ... and God we hate unknowns and don't wish to know eM!

 

Most wishes are fulfilled, some of us get bi ID ...

Back to Religion and Faith topics