Freundly-Giant's picture

Freundly-Giant

image

Should old treaties still apply?

In present day society, should we still let old treaties apply to Native Canadians? A promise was made, but with the present condition many Native Canadians appear to be in, should they still be granted differant rights and responcibilities?

Share this

Comments

GordW's picture

GordW

image

Well we might want to try living up to them in spirit and in letter.  That would be a change.

 

But what would you suggest to replace it?  I think a new way of inter-relating is in order I am just not sure what it might look like.

Freundly-Giant's picture

Freundly-Giant

image

If it were up to me to make the change, I'd try to slowly move natives and their culture alike into the visibility of everybody else and slowly lessen the legal gap between natives and the rest of Canada.

retiredrev's picture

retiredrev

image

Are we going to apply this standard to other peoples or groups?  One of my ancestors had a huge parcel of land in Quebec that included the area in and around Riviere-du-loup.   Hey, his half a million descendants want that back, too!    Once we start with past treaties, the 'land claims', etc., where does it end?  My Huguenot ancestors had to flee France and had their lands taken from them.  Do we go back and get what was rightfully theirs?  At some point, you have to let go of history and plan for today and the future.

revjohn's picture

revjohn

image

Hi Freundly-Giant,

 

Freundly-Giant wrote:

In present day society, should we still let old treaties apply to Native Canadians?

 

Is there a time limit on integrity?

 

Freundly-Giant wrote:

A promise was made, but

 

A promise was made.  No buts.

 

Freundly-Giant wrote:

with the present condition many Native Canadians appear to be in, should they still be granted differant rights and responcibilities?

 

Are they so well off that they get much more than others?  Are they getting richer at our expense?  What about present day conditions should release the Federal Government from their responsibilities?

 

Grace and peace to you.

John

Freundly-Giant's picture

Freundly-Giant

image

I don't think that the government should still keep up their responcibility; the responcibility to make sure Native Canadians are given all that they need to survive and prosper. The way that the government is handling the responcibilty isn't fulfilling that promise.

Back to Social topics
cafe